Lucy Peyton’s niece Sarah Jane Peyton
One of our Smith/Duncan grandmothers was Lucy Peyton. Lucy moved from Virginia to Mississippi in 1834. However, most of her siblings and their children remained in Virginia, including an unmarried niece named Sarah Jane.
Sarah, a spinster, lived quietly with her brother Randolph in the small town of Port Royal, Virginia. Here is their house today, boarded up and abandoned:
One ordinary Monday evening many years ago Randolph was gone from the house, leaving Sarah alone. Around dark three men arrived on horseback. One, a man named Willie, was known to Sarah. The other two were strangers.
Sarah Jane invited them in. Willie explained that the two strangers were former Confederate soldiers, one wounded, who needed a place to stay the night. Robert E. Lee had surrendered just two weeks earlier and the two soldiers were headed home.
Sarah Jane considered the situation. Her sympathies were Southern and she likely wanted to be kind to travelers but this situation would put her in a house with several unknown men while her brother was gone. She decided that they had to leave the house.
The men understood. Sarah Jane and Willie discussed options and agreed that the party should try the farm house of Richard Garrett, about two miles away.
The men remounted their horses and left, moving down the road to the Garrett farm. Farmer Garrett allowed the three men to stay the night in his house. The next day the farmer told the men to sleep in the barn that night and then move on. The men bedded down in the barn.
That night, well after midnight, riders arrived at Garrett’s house, looking for two men. Garrett told the riders that there were two travelers sleeping in the barn. The riders dismounted and surrounded the barn that contained the two strangers who earlier wanted to stay at Sarah Jane’s house.
The rest of the story is well-covered by American history books. The riders, who were federal cavalry, surrounded the barn. They ordered the two travelers to leave the barn and, when one of the travelers refused to come out, they set the barn on fire. The reluctant traveler, trapped in a burning barn, finally came out with his pistol drawn. The soldiers shot, hitting him in the neck.
They placed the mortally-wounded traveler on farmer Garrett’s front porch where, several hours later, the mysterious traveler, John Wilkes Booth, died.
Farmer Garrett suffered from housing John Wilkes Booth. The fire destroyed his farm equipment and supplies, his means of feeding his large family. He became a public villian and his family said he suffered emotional wounds that never healed.
I imagine that cousin Sarah Jane, and the Peyton family in general, was thankful that Randolph had not been home on April 24, 1865.